The Real Work of a Project Manager: Where Theory Meets Reality

Hey Friend 👋

Early in my career, I genuinely believed I needed all the answers. Someone asks about the timeline? Have an answer. Stakeholder questions the approach? Explain it. Team member uncertain? Tell them what to do.

Then I watched a senior PM handle a tense stakeholder meeting. Instead of defending or explaining, she asked: "What does success look like for you?" Then: "What's your biggest concern if we go down this path?" The room shifted. People started talking. Assumptions surfaced. We left with clarity we never would've reached through answers alone.

That's when it hit me: the real work isn't having all the answers. It's asking the right questions.

The real work of a PM? It's asking the right questions.

Here's what I eventually learned: most problems in projects come from assumptions. The antidote? Just ask.

Ask for clarification. Ask about concerns. Ask what success looks like. Ask if everyone actually understands. Too many PMs think they need all the answers. Actually, you need to ask all the right questions.

This is what fills your day: asking questions that uncover risks before they hit, questions that challenge assumptions, questions that help people say what they're actually worried about, questions that keep purpose visible when everyone's lost in details.

The job description says "manage stakeholders." Reality says "translate what the CEO wants into something the team can actually deliver, and vice versa." And you do that by asking, not by assuming.

The real skill isn't having all the answers ready. It's knowing what to ask, when to ask it, and actually listening to what surfaces.

Next time you're tempted to make an assumption: Ask instead. Ask for clarity. Ask what concerns people have. Ask if everyone's really aligned. The discomfort of asking lasts seconds. The cost of not asking can last months.

What's a question you wish you'd asked earlier on a project? Hit reply. I read them all and often feature reader insights in future newsletters.

Want to go deeper?

I've written a full deep-dive on the power of asking questions (including the coffee discount experiment that changed how I approach conversations), or try the Mindcast where you can actually do the experiment yourself and practice asking in realistic PM scenarios.

A Quick Word: Finding Your Why

I've always been inspired by Simon Sinek's work on finding your why. Building this platform forced me to establish mine, not just as inspiration, but as a compass.

When my creative flow is at an all-time high, the why keeps me focused. When it disappears completely, the why reminds me what I'm actually doing this for: making project management more accessible and moving the industry forward.

Asking yourself "why am I building this?" when things look bleak helps calibrate your purpose. It's not about motivation. It's about remembering what matters when everything else feels uncertain. Find your why. Write it down. You'll need it.

Enjoying The PM Notebook? Share it with a colleague. Explore more insights and interactive experiences at bilaljamil.com.

Take care and speak soon,
Bilal Jamil